AN JIE
STEVE
ESSAY
Assisted Suicide In China many years ago, a mother of terminally ill her son required practice euthanasia. Then the man was sued for the crime of homicide case by procuratorial organs, and the Supreme People’s court adjudicated him acquittal. Later the man advanced gastric cancer and he required assisted suicide, but his required was refused. Since the event has happened, Chinese people argued whether China should practice assisted suicide. And people also talked about whether China should build laws about actualizing assisted suicide; although someone strongly agreed with practiced assisted suicide, people still considered Chinese social security system was not good enough which could not guaranteed execution the action success. There were few countries to legalize euthanasia, and those countries had strict and detailed requirements for that. This prevented doctors to kill patients or hospital cover up medical negligence. However, even in perfect legal system countries such as America those measures cannot assure that there are not “devil doctors”. On the other hand, portion of people considered assisted suicide that was better choice for terminally illness patients. They paid attention on the point the assisted suicide could make no painful to die. Now, we got both side’s opinions, from the square side, some part of people are willing to accept assisted suicide, there are three reasons: first, people say life is private personal stuff, so people absolutely can choose death that also is human’s right. Second, government gives enough intendance then practice assisted suicide will operate success. Third, people should respect personal’s choice and follow patient’s willing that is humane, and this helps family to get free of money’s pressures. That is my opinion also; I think assisted suicide can reduce painful for patient, which is important point. From the anti-side, a number of people think should not practice assisted suicide, for: at first, life belongs to community, but not belong to individuals. Then, assisted suicide might be used by people who attempt to misdemeanor, because the supervisory agency can not ensure per case’s every steps are inerrant. Finally, the anti-side defines assisted suicide which is a selfish act, and this kind of action will cause painful for relatives that is not humane. At the following paragraphs, I will clarify anti-side’s opinions which do not agree with practice assisted suicide, and I will defend for my opinions which favor assisted suicide.
The anti-side’s first reason for objection assisted suicide which they consider the people’s life belongs to community, not belong to individuals. Virtually, they think the people’s life defines persons’ meaning in social. People should be responsible for community; they should be responsible for relatives, and they also should be responsible for themselves. People are not alone; they can not give up live rashly. There are still relatives desiring people’s concern. It is rash behavior of taking assisted suicide that would hurt relatives. People should face the situation bravely instead of hiding. In addition, the medical sciences are improving step by step; people must keep hopes for surviving. From the other hand, the square side, they favor assisted suicide which they think people’s life belongs to individuals, people have right to decide their life and death issues. I have to say I agree with square side’s opinion. Every counties appeal people should have human rights instead of autocracy. Within the framework of law people can do whatever they want, I think that include decide to die. Some people define assisted suicide as rash behavior and irresponsible action. That is disguised form of behavior restriction. Suppose if people have no rights to do whatever they want within the framework of law, which is autocracy. I think decide death issue that is essential human right, which is personal affair. This is not hurt society interests, and it is benefit for society interests. It is one way to reduce social pressure. I do not believe personal death issue relating to society interests. Society will not go to pieces just because one person died that is incredible. No one will believe that kind of statement. Furthermore, patients take assisted suicide which does not mean irresponsible, rash behavior. Depending on relatives do not want patients suffering so much painful you can not say that is giving up life. Actually, this is reflection of humanity. Oppositely, people inhibit patients taking assisted suicide, standing ailment, spending expensive treatment, and watching relatives anxious; there are not humanity, this is torture and hurt. I can not believe people want to do the shameful things. I have to say I strongly agree with practice assisted suicide.
When people talk about some things instead of doing that is really easy. For practice assisted suicide is also difficult to do. In my opinions, if government sets enough supervisory authorities to watch each other that will help practice assisted suicide success. We should arrange professional custodians to control the process to guarantee all steps correctly. These are the most important steps. For the people who object assisted suicide they think setting supervisory authorities that will not work because Chinese law system is not perfect. Even in American which country has perfect law system does not make assisted suicide legal because people afraid of someone who will use it to get other ulterior motives. Such as “devil doctors”, few hospitals will kill patients to cover up the medical malpractice; certain doctors will kill patients to gain organs selling them; and some doctors will us e died bodies from patients to do experiments. These situations will prevent assisted suicide operation smoothly. There are too many people, and that will not easy to control.
For the last reason which is the most important reason to defend my opinion about favor assisted suicide. I think follow patients’ opinions and respect patients’ willing that are significant keys. Maybe those kinds of people are patients but they are human first. They do have rights for what they want to do, and what they want to choose. Therefore, they do have right to choose assisted suicide to reduce painful. The other people should respect patients’ choice and willing instead of stopping them to do some things. Moreover, practice assisted suicide that will help family to save money. I think if the patients decide to practice assisted suicide then they can donate organs to make money for family. I know that sounds like inhumane but it is really effective. And that really help patients decreasing painful. Patients donate their organs not only helps family to get free of money’s pressure but makes more chance for other patients who need transplanting organs. In China, there are more than thousands patients need surgery of transplanting organs, but hospitals have not enough organs to transplant. Due to this reason, patients died one by one; and people can not do anything for that. I have to say people should really follow patients’ opinions and willing. On the other hand, the antis think practice assisted suicide that is kind of murder although patients are willing. People should not allow doctors to practice assisted suicide, which is rash and irresponsible behavior. And the point is the patients just pay attention on their painful, they ignore the relatives’ painful. Those patients are too selfish they even do not care other people’s feeling. The relatives do not want patients to die they hope patients stay as long as they can. People consider the medical sciences are advanced and improving every day. People should not lose hope for doctors and sciences. Especially patients themselves should believe doctors can help them. People take assisted suicide that will cause too much painful for relatives. In addition, making money by donation organs that will make relatives feeling guilt, not reduce pressure. So some people said practice assisted suicide that was selfish and rash behavior.
From these reasons, I have to say I favor practice assisted suicide. We know life belongs to individuals and people can control their life to make best choice. Not only people can control their life but we should follow patients’ opinions and willing, which is kind of respect for people. And practice assisted suicide government should give enough surveillance that would help it operates achievement. For now, lots of people object assisted suicide because they can not stand died relatives’ bodies separated. In the future, I believe there are more and more people will favor assisted suicide.
